Today: Lawfare highlights Matthew Tokson's argument that warrantless automated license plate reader searches likely violate the Fourth Amendment. Businesses handling vehicle-location records should review law-enforcement disclosure procedures, while distinguishing this legal analysis from a binding rule applicable to their operations.
Privacy Developments
The Week That Was
Summary: Matthew Tokson argues that automated license plate reader (ALPR) systems can expose extensive location histories and likely violate the Fourth Amendment when used without a warrant. Lawfare's roundup describes Chatrie v. United States as a Supreme Court decision requiring a warrant to obtain Google Maps data and says that decision has informed lower-court concerns about ALPRs. This is an account of legal analysis, not a determination that every ALPR deployment or private-sector disclosure is unconstitutional.
- Compliance Action: If your organization collects plate-reader records or provides access to law enforcement, have counsel verify the cited decision, its scope, and controlling authority in the relevant jurisdiction before changing disclosure requirements. Review whether police can query your systems directly, what authorization is required, and how requests and disclosures are documented. Treat this as a recommended review, not a newly established compliance deadline.
- Source: Lawfare
Compliance Takeaways
- Inventory ALPR access: Identify vehicle-location records your organization holds, retention periods, vendors with access, and any direct law-enforcement connections. An inventory identifies arrangements to review, not proof of a constitutional violation.
- Verify Fourth Amendment applicability: Ask counsel to confirm Chatrie v. United States, subsequent ALPR decisions, and their applicability to the specific government access or disclosure being considered.
- Document disclosure decisions: Review procedures for validating legal demands, escalating requests to counsel, and recording the authority and scope of each disclosure. Do not assume the same warrant standard applies to every request.